From the Wall Street Journal:
A New Bromide: Brine Is Much Better Than Oil in Arkansas
SMACKOVER, Ark.- Theres a saying here when drillers strike oil:
"Darn." In southern Arkansas, the big driller prefer saltwater. And
oil? "Its a nuisance," says one briny veteran. For 40 years, a
10-mile-by-50-mile swalth through the pine forests here has been the worlds largest
supplier of bromine, a crucial chemical element whose uses include fireproofing plastics
for electronic equipment. Mined from subterranean saltwater deposited by ancient oceans,
the bromine-rich brine long ago surpassed oil in economic importance to the state.
But in Arkansas-- "the Natural State"--the industry has never
received much respect. The two major producers here have been squabbling for years. And
now the business faces a new rival on the other side of the world: the Dead Sea.
So thick in minerals that swimmers bob like corks in the water, the Dead Sea has proved to
be a richer--and cheaper--source of bromine than Arkansas is. Poised for rapid expansion,
the Dead Seas industry threatens to supplant Arkansas as bromine capital of the
world.
Brine has always been less glamorous than oil. Rocks in this state have
more sex appeal. "Clearly, oil has more pizazz than brine," says a manager for
the bromine business. When bromine was found to be a superb flame retardant in the
1960s, the market for the chemical exploded. Today (2000), the world bromine market is
worth about $800 million, with about half of the production coming from Arkansas. In
addition to flame retardants, bromine is used in pesticides and fungicides,
pharmaceuticals, photography, water treatment and oil-field drilling fluids.
On a recent wintry day, field supervisor Floyd Green drove his pickup
down a muddy road to the companys first new brine well in three years. "People
in oil still dont understand the brine business," say Mr. Green.
"Its hard for them to imagine what we would want with saltwater."
Oil just gets in the way. Six of Albemarles 27 producing wells also pump a
few barrels of oil a day. The oil has to be extracted from the brine, then stored until
theres enough of it to sell.
But drilling for brine isnt for wimps. Brine wells are twice as
big and twice as deep as the typical Arkansas oil well. And the stuff that comes out is
much nastier: There is more poison gas, which can kill you in your tracks. Corrosive
fluids often exceed 230 degrees in the ground and can curl the toes of your boots.
"They just turn right up and look at you," says Mr. Green, who has ruined many a
pair. Green tells of a rookie who fled in horror after a senior brine worker, his
face etched with 50 years of work in the fields, advised him not to let the brine get on
his skin.
While the two companies contend with each other, a bigger threat is
coming from the Dead Sea, sandwiched between Israel and Jordan, which has a third of the
market and is gaining fast. Instead of drilling for brine, Dead Sea companies can just
scoop it out at about 60% of the cost that is incurred in Arkansas. Drawn from evaporation
pits, Dead Sea brine contains as much has 10,000 pounds of bromine in every million pounds
of brine. That compares with about 5,000 parts per million for Arkansas brine and about 65
parts per million for Gulf Coast seawater.
Until recently, Israel has dominated bromine production.
Even more ominous for Arkansas (and Michigan), bromine reserves in the
state are expected to last about 50 more years, while the Dead Sea promises to have
reserves for 1,000 years.
|